Superman: The Animated Series is a great series, while not as epic as Batman: The Animated Series, it is the definitive Superman. Perhaps the series failed to differentiate between Clark Kent and Superman as well as it should have. Clark was just a regular guy in this version as opposed to the overly nerdy version portrayed by Christopher Reeves. They appeared to be taking a page out of the Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman book with Dean Cain’s portrayal of the character. An absolutely brilliant decision.
Superman is supposed to be a happier character, more positive. Ultimately the show was darker than BtAS ever was. Batman is a dark character so throwing glimmers of positively have more impact. Superman is a positive character which means balance to the stories required darker spins.
Superman lacks the robust rogues gallery Batman has. Coming up with meaningful villains to fight Superman is difficult for any writer. The shows early episodes were on point. It was the follow-up episodes which didn’t have the same resonance. So the show had nice introductions or reimaginations of villains but no plan on how to handle their follow-up episodes. The show did hit it right with the Darkseid stories and basically created a Superman story arc revolving around the character. A story arc the lie action films tried and failed to replicate.
Tim Daly as the voice of Superman was the perfect choice. Known for his role on the NBC sitcom Wings, this was an interesting choice. Even though he played the straight man on the show, it was still a comedic background in acting. How could that translate to mild mannered Clark Kent and larger than life Superman? Daly’s take on the character was Clark Kent is the guy, Superman is just a name people gave him. All Superman’s actions and decisions are those of Clark Kent, there is no alter ego. A similar take reflected in the live action TV show Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman starring Dean Cain and Teri Hatcher. While Lois & Clark’s success was winding down and would be canceled only nine month’s later (after four seasons), it’s clear the better story points of the show had an influence on the cartoon.
Written by
Joseph Ammendolea
Owner/President
“I Like To Play With Toys” Productions®
ILikeToPlayWithToysProductions@Yahoo.com